The Lag Effect: Alcohol impairment persists hours after BAC declines

In the first of our three-part series about driver intoxication, we reveal how impairment persists for hours after blood alcohol concentration falls.

BAC peaked 1.5 hours after drinking alcohol, while impairment peaked at the five-hour mark.
Understanding the relationship between blood alcohol concentration (BAC) and impairment is critical to improving road safety and moving us closer to Vision Zero. Optalert recently completed a study that sheds light on the nature of impairment due to alcohol.

A comprehensive study on impairment due to alcohol

Optalert engaged KEA Technologies in Boston to conduct a comprehensive study on how impairment develops after consumption of alcohol. It involved 30 diverse participants with no sleep disorders or other potential confounding factors.

Participants were diverse across all characteristics and screened to ensure they had no background impairment from sleep disorders or drug use.

Each participant began at 10:00 a.m. with a BAC of 0.00%. Their baseline impairment was measured and then they consumed alcohol. This study did something very different to prior research: BAC and impairment were measured repeatedly over the entire day as the participant processed the alcohol. The test ended when they returned a BAC reading of 0.00% or eight hours had elapsed.

Measuring objective impairment

Impairment was measured with the Johns Test of Vigilance (JTV), created by Optalert founder and sleep science pioneer, Dr. Murray Johns.

The JTV is a 15-minute test that was refined over years to measure the precise form of psychomotor impairment that indicates a person is unfit to drive. The test participant sees three circles. Every 5 to 15 seconds, the circles momentarily change to diamonds and squares for 400 milliseconds. The participant must click a button each time the shapes change. Non-response within 2 seconds is recorded as an error of omission (EOO).

At a glance: BAC versus Impairment
Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) is the amount of alcohol in the bloodstream, typically measured as a percentage. For example, a BAC of 0.08% means there are 0.08 grams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood. Factors like bodyweight, metabolism, and alcohol tolerance influence how rapidly BAC peaks and declines.
Impairment refers to the decline in a person’s mental or physical capabilities. This can affect essential driving skills such as reaction, decision-making, and coordination. Optalert defines impairment in its study through errors of omission in the Johns Test of Vigilance. This test tracks non-response to a visual stimulus, pinpointing moments when someone’s attention falters.

The discovery: BAC leads, impairment follows hours later

The trajectory of BAC was unsurprising. On average, it peaked 1.5 hours after drinking alcohol and took about 6 hours to fall back to 0.00%.

However, people’s impairment lagged far behind, peaking about 5 hours after drinking alcohol – even in participants well below the legal limit for driving under the influence (DUI)!

This finding has major implications for road safety.

Drivers remain significantly impaired for hours - even when BAC drops.

This delay in impairment is striking because many drivers would assume they are “sober enough” to drive as their BAC begins to drop.

However, their psychomotor impairment will actually be increasing for many hours. This lag effect is a powerful reminder that drivers with a BAC under the legal limit may still be impaired. In turn, a driver monitoring system could detect this and enact countermeasures to improve road safety.

This is why BAC and impairment do not correlate in previous research.

The difference between BAC and impairment can be attributed to how alcohol affects the brain and body. 

After drinking, alcohol spreads quickly through the bloodstream. While BAC measures how much alcohol is in the blood at a given time, this elevated level of alcohol has yet to have full impact on the impairment levels. This is why we saw BAC peaking around the 90-minute mark in our study, but impairment rising far more slowly and persisting a lot longer. Many participants were significantly impaired above baseline even when they had returned to a BAC of 0.00%. 

What questions remain unanswered?

  • This work needs to be replicated in an on-track study validating against an objective performance metric such as two wheels out of lane (WOOL) twice within 15 minutes (WOOL 2×15).
  • In our study, participants rapidly consumed a large dose of alcohol and then had no more for the rest of the day. Obviously, this does not match how people usually consume alcohol in naturalistic scenarios. A longer drinking period prior to cessation should be studied to see how impairment progresses when the ascending BAC curve is longer.
  • This research only looked at psychomotor impairment. Further work needs to be done on impaired judgement and especially increased risk-seeking behaviours and aggression. This may peak in the earlier excitatory phase of alcohol, before the later depressant effects develop.
Cybernetic artificial intelligence in three-dimensional logic space on quantum computing communication of abstract Plexus elements array. 3D illustration concept loop for music, logic, and meditation.

Optalert can help you validate your system

At Optalert, we are dedicated to advancing technology that improves road safety. Our team is continually researching new eyelid-based biomarkers to detect impairment and keep road users safe.

Contact Optalert to explore how we can work together to revolutionise the field of road safety.